subscribe

AmericaSpace-Standing together to explore together.

February 8th, 2010

In case any of you would like to play with the budget numbers for NASA, we have this nice little spreadsheet that shows the budget for NASA based on the 2010 and 2011 budgets. And those numbers are very different. Not only is the White House trying to cancel Constellation, bit it is also creating some new budget line items that it has not discussed at any length, even though those lines add up to over $500 billion.


No
Comments
February 8th, 2010

Carter: Protect U.S. Industrial Base – Defense News: “”

One of the criticisms that those who opposed government run human space flight activities focuses on whether NASA should really be a jobs program. Last year, in an interview with Defense News, Undersecretary of Defense Ashton Carter stated his strong belief that some jobs are worth keeping because they are not easily replicated in commercial industry and therefore difficult to replace.

I feel industrial base issues are completely legitimate because having the best defense industrial and technology base in the world is not a birthright.

It’s not about jobs, it’s about certain kinds of jobs: very rare kinds of skills that are not easily replicated in the commercial world and, if allowed to erode, would be difficult to rebuild.

It’s also interesting that the Secretary of Defense testified on Wednesday before the House Armed Services Committee that neither he nor anyone at DoD was consulted with concerning the cuts to NASA and the outsourcing of Constellation’s Ares V, which would have provided the DoD with a heavy lift capability.

No
Comments
February 8th, 2010

Update: We’ve corrected Sen. Hutchison’s address and added Representative Mollahan.

Some have asked whether there is another way to get the Constellation support letter and contacts of Senators to write to. You ask; we deliver.

3
Comments
February 8th, 2010

Check out this new petition in support of the Constellation program. It takes a different tack on justifying the continuing of Constellation. More voices of support mean that we can stop the attempt to end our nation’s human space flight program.

1
Comment

Tags:
, , , , ,

February 8th, 2010

Charlie Bolden At KSC Press Conference - AP Photo

Providing a great service to the space community, NasaWatch has a copy of Charlie Bolden’s Saturday press conference at Kennedy Space Center. It isn’t pretty. On many occasions, Administrator Bolden doesn’t answer the questions that point out some of the…well, issues, of his decision to cancel Constellation and our country’s human space flight program. Instead, he seques into tangential issues. Three reporters stood out: Todd Halvorson of Florida Today, Ken Chang of the New York Times, and Tony Winton of Associated Press. These three asked the most pressing and pointed questions of the whole event.

Gary Miles analysis of Bolden’s Saturday press conference at Kennedy Space Center was spot on, that is:
1) Constellation program was within its funding profile.
2) Constellation was not over budget.
3) The greatest significant factor in Constellation schedule delay, timeline, was level of funding.
4) The reason for cancellation of Constellation program was purely budgetary.
5) Technical problems with Ares I was not a significant factor or even a factor at all in Constellation cancellation or in delay of program.

I’ll add that, towards the end of the event, Bolden states that he doesn’t see HLV flights until decade between 2020 – 2030

Here are a couple of good Q & A’s from the event:

Todd Halvorson – Florida Today
You want to talk to Congress about destinations. What do you tell Congress when it says that we’ve already had that conversation in 2005 and 2008 and affirmed the program of record (Constellation)?
NASA Administrator Bolden
We could not get where we want to go using the program of record and that was purely budgetary. There is no criticism of Constellation on technical capability. The engineers who designed Constellation were competent and capable. Constellation was well run. Mike Griffin never had enough money but since he worked for the President, he couldn’t stand on a mountain top and shout that out. This nation was blessed to have someone like Mike Griffin, a rocket scientist, lead NASA and help design Constellation. We are better for it.

Ken Chang – NYTimes
For last couple of years, Constellation managers said program was facing some typical technical challenges but was on schedule and budget and Ares I would fly in 2017 and commercial 2016. Why is NASA much more confident in commercial 2016 and not confident with NASA’s own people’s claim that Ares I would fly in 2015?
Bolden
Starts talking about how a program is on-budget. All programs remain on budget but stretches out the program schedule. But the time-horizon had stretched out. Bolden depends upon the Augustine Committee as his technical analysis of Constellation and Ares I in particular. Bolden agrees with almost all of Augustine Committee conclusions. He hears what commercials are saying of their launch date and costs, but doesn’t know if its true. Could be differences between what Augustine Committee knew or where they are today.

No
Comments

Tags:
, , , , ,

February 7th, 2010

Update: We’ve corrected Sen. Hutchison’s address and added Representative Mollahan

We have written what we hope might serve as a kernel for your own letters to members of Congress about the Obama Administration’s efforts to take the U.S. out of human space flight. Of course, make any changes you like.

If you do want to write your own letter, here are a few points to help make your correspondence more effective:

  • Include your name, address and the date of the letter.
  • Include an RE: The topic of your letter
  • Start with what you are writing about.
  • Why you support/oppose?
  • What you would like your Congressional representative to do.
  • Please, no insulting language or vulgarity–it will only cause your letter to be tossed.

The following folks are the ones you who have leadership roles in the Senate and House Appropriations Committees. But also don’t forget to write your own Congressional representative and Senators.

Senator Barbara Mikulski
503 Hart Senate Office Building
Washington, DC 20510
(202) 224-4654

Senator Bill Nelson
716 Hart Senate Office Building
Washington, DC 20510
(202) 224-5274

Senator Richard Shelby
304 Hart Senate Office Building
Washington, DC 20510
(202) 224-5744

Senator Kay Hutchison
284 Russell Senate Office Building
Washington, DC 20510
(202) 224-5922

Senator Thad Cochran
113 Dirksen Senate Office Building
Washington, DC 20510
(202) 224-5922

Senator Daniel Inouye
722 Hart Senate Office Building
Washington, DC 20510
(202) 224-3934

Representative Alan Mollohan
2302 Rayburn House Office Building
Washington, DC 20515
(202) 225-7564

SaveConstellationTemplate-Word

No
Comments
February 7th, 2010

Pro Constellation groups have sprouted across facebook over this past week in fast response to the President’s proposed budget plans to cancel the Constellation Program. These groups are led by everyday American’s who want a say in the future of their space program. We have started our own group on facebook and want to recommend several others for people to join in support of Constellation and human spaceflight.

AmericaSpace

Save NASA’s Constellation and Manned Spaceflight Program

Support NASA and the Space Program

No
Comments
February 7th, 2010

On Monday, the White House and NASA executive management proposed terminating Project Constellation and starting fresh with the commercial launchers, none of whom have built anything that can launch more than a refrigerator, never mind a crew, into low-earth orbit. NASA Administrator Bolden put out a upbeat statement about the new direction NASA was taking.

That same day, NASA Deputy Administrator Garver was extolling the virtues on NASA’s new direction and said of Glenn Research Center, near Cleveland, Ohio, “I just think they are so well-suited for this forward-going program,”. No such comforting words were offered to Marshall Space Flight Center, Johnson Space Center, and Kennedy Space Center, which were cumulatively looking at over 10,000 job losses due to this forward-going program.

On Tuesday, NASA Administrator Bolden stated “We’re not abandoning human spaceflight by any stretch of the imagination,” Bolden said at the National Press Club in a speech promoting Obama’s budget, released Monday. “I think we’re going to get there perhaps quicker than we would have done before.” By that time, however, people ranging from former Apollo astronauts such as Walt Cunningham and Gene Cernan to Shuttle astronauts, famous writers, and many politicians were making it pretty clear that NASA’s new policies were DOA.

Come Wednesday, NASA Administrator Bolden, feeling a bit combative, told NASA employees that he understood many were upset, but that neither he nor the president intended to back down on plans to cancel the Constellation program and hand responsibility for operating rockets to private companies. Just to amp things up a bit, Bolden exclaimed that it was time for NASA employees to “get with the program”. In explaining his decision to terminate Constellation, Bolden said that in the current “dire” fiscal climate he could not ethically recommend to the president that pouring tens of billions more dollars into Constellation was essential.”

By Friday, it seems that the hew and cry from…well, everyone in Congress was starting to get NASA’s leadership’s attention. To start-off with, Homer Hickam, author of, “Rocket Boys“, the book that formed the story for, “October Sky“, had written both NASA Deputy Administrator Lori Garver and White House Science Advisor asking that they resign over their managerial and policy incompetance. And just to add some spice, Hickam then wrote Representative Bart Gordon, Chairman of the House Committee on Science and Technology, telling him of his letters, the reason for them, and his willingness, more like enthusiasm, to testify before Gordon’s Committee. Of course, there was a Facebook group, Save NASA’s Constellation and Manned Space Flight Program that had grown from 0 to 9,800 members in less than 5 days, and by tonight was 11,247 members. Or there was Support The Constellation Program, which grew from 0 to 1,200 members. If that wasn’t enough, Support NASA and the Space Program was coming in at 2,220 members. A YouTube video parodying Hitler’s reaction upon hearing that Obama was abandoning human space flight with the subtitle, “I knew he did it only to win Florida”, which was true, and closing with, “Cancel my NasaTV” was going viral. Some were too “offended” to link to the video, though those same folks never had any problems casting aspersions to Mike Griffin or Steve Cook. By the end of Friday, another video, “Save Constellation“, by TauFox had over 89,000 views. No matter how you looked at NASA’s policy, things were getting very hot for NASA’s management.

Now, it’s Saturday. A day of relaxation, BBQ, Shuttle launches, and mea culpas. Or at least, damage control. In an article by CNN, NASA Administrator Bolden was reported singing a far different tune than Wednesday’s “Get with the program” mantra and had instead shifted to expressing concerns for NASA job looses and professions that “The reason why the NASA work force is not better prepared was because I didn’t listen to people … who talked about how we should roll these things out,” Bolden said. “I thought I knew better, to be quite honest. So we rolled out the budget, we rolled out everything in the manner we did and it was screwed up.”  According to CNN, Bolden said he hopes to recoup about 1,000 jobs by persuading Congress to keep some or all of the Constellation’s Ares program, and that he was involved in talks on Capitol Hill. “Those are the sorts of negotiations I have to do,” he added. He didn’t mention which Ares, Ares I or Ares V. So, as far as anyone in the Save Constellation movement is concerned, more pressure needed.

1
Comment
February 6th, 2010

NASA v. US Budget

There have been a few people make the mistake of assuming that lowering NASA’s budget will lower the deficit. Our NASA Administrator and his Deputy, for example. While in the aggregate, yes, subtracting $5 B/year from a $1.276 T deficit does lower that amount, it’s by just a hair’s, or more precisely by 0.4%. So, here are pictures.

These are based on 2011 U.S. Budget numbers:

  • U.S. Budget – $3.721 T
  • U.S. Discretionary Budget – $1.415 T
  • U.S. Non-Discretionary Budget – $2.31 T
  • U.S. Budget Deficit – $1.267 T
  • NASA Budget – $19 B
  • Constellation Budget – $5.54 B

If you want the full spreadsheet, that includes both the pre- and post-kill human space flight numbers, here you go…

NASA Budget Estimates 2008 – 2014

No
Comments

Tags:
, , , , , , ,

February 6th, 2010

Homer Hickam Author of "Rocket Boys"

In post on his blog, Homer Hickam Online, Homer Hickam, aerospace engineer, author of, “Rocket Boys“, the book on which the movie, “October Sky” was based, wrote Representative Bart Gordon and members of the House Committee on Science & Technology of his correspondence, sent directly to White House Science Advisor John Holdren and NASA Deputy Administrator Lori Garver asking them to resign for their unwarranted policy change to cancel our country’s human space flight program.

It’s a powerful, passionate, yet reasoned letter that, at the end, you come to agree with. Homer is right and I hope Congress will hear his voice.

1
Comment
February 6th, 2010

Sci-Fi Science Guy Thinks Obama Space Plane Short-Sighted

Michio Kaku, Theoretical Physics Professor and host of, “Sci-Fi Science”, has a lot to say about the President’s new human space flight policy, none of it good, in his interview on Fox News. Sadly, I am unable to remove the commercial at the start of the Fox News clip. Still, an interview that was one of the more probing.

No
Comments
February 5th, 2010

Thanks to the folks at Save NASA’s Constellation and Manned Space Flight Program for this:

Although it can feel good to openly vent about the proposed 2011 NASA budget, if you are seriously interested in having a say, now is your opportunity to steer the course of history. Should several thousand letters (not email, which is ignored) reach Senators Bill Nelson, Barbara Mikulski, Richard Shelby, and Kay Hutchison, they can and will have an major impact upon the future direction of NASA. Unlike old age and taxes, the death of Constellation is not at all a certainty. Because of language put into last year’s budget by Senator Shelby, America’s human space flight porgram Constellation will continue to be NASA’s plan of record until Congress specifically says otherwise.

For the cost of 4 first class stamps, which is not too expensive compared to the 9 billion dollars invested in Constellation, and the loss of many thousands of talented engineers, your voice will be heard. Your letter does not need to be long, and should be to the point.

Send your written letters to the following address.

Mikulski, Barbara A. – (D – MD)
503 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING
WASHINGTON DC 20510
(202) 224-4654

Nelson, Bill – (D – FL)
716 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING
WASHINGTON DC 20510
(202) 224-5274

Shelby, Richard C. – (R – AL)
304 RUSSELL SENATE OFFICE… BUILDING
WASHINGTON DC 20510
(202) 224-5744

Hutchison, Kay Bailey – (R – TX)
284 RUSSELL SENATE OFFICE BUILDING
WASHINGTON DC 20510
(202) 224-5922

By not writing, you could easily be casting a vote against Constellation.

No
Comments
February 5th, 2010

The Examiner article, “Obama’s NASA Plans–A non-starter” is the best reporting I’ve read summarizing the commercial companies that want to take over our nation’s human role in ensuring America has access to space, to the space station and beyond. It also brings into sharp focus the…well, recklessness of the Obama Administration’s move against our country’s human space flight program.

A review of these ‘NewSpace’ companies show a slew of starry-eyed dreamers either too naïve or untruthful with themselves to admit they are as Congressman Shelby called them.

It is a bitter comedy that a recent article posted on Space.com quotes these quacks as saying that we will be seeing space tourism by 2020 – no that is not a typo – these folks believe, having launched next to nothing and being more successful at failing than at firing off rockets that we will all blast off on their rockets within 10 years!

No
Comments
February 5th, 2010

In a long line of great adaptations, someone has now produce, “Hitler Finds Out Obama Canceled Constellation“.

If some are offended, please accept our deepest apologies. This is a parody, gallows humor if you will, of the current situation concerning our human space program. We are definitely NOT equating the President, who despite our differences concerning NASA, we respect a great deal. In fact, this video about a reaction to the President’s action, not a comparison or equating of the President to Adolf Hitler.

That this sort of sharp humor is rising up from the masses should be an indication to NASA executive management that their decision to change this country’s direction in human space flight based on their own pre-concieved notions and not on facts or analysis is not going over well at all.

Hitler Finds Out That Obama Killed Constellation

No
Comments

Tags:
, , , , , , ,

February 5th, 2010

This is a message I recieved form somone at JPL. It shows that the shock and unrest spawned by the Administration’s attempt at killing America’s human space flight program. I have to admit that I am surprised at the reaction at JPL to The news of Constellation’s demise. JPL’s budget will go a bit up in the Obama budget. It really shows that NASA is a team, that people of differing stripes value our human space program.

A surprising number of JPL’ers have been telling me that they have had trouble working this week because they feel so derailed by the jolt to human spaceflight. I’m glad to see that so many people here are inspired to see people and not just robots in space.

No
Comments